Comparison of BYD Atto 3 and Tesla Model Y Electric SUVs
May 1, 2023
This is a detailed comparison of the characteristics and qualities of two popular electric SUVs in Australia: the BYD Atto, a small SUV, and the Tesla Model Y, a medium-sized SUV. To make the comparison as accurate as possible, we’ll be looking at the specific versions of each car that are most similar:
The price of the Model Y and the Atto 3 is different because they have different features like power, acceleration, battery size, and driving range.
The Model Y has a bigger battery than the Extended Range Atto 3. This is why the Tesla Model Y RWD costs between $19k to $23k more than the BYD Atto 3 Extended Range after on-road costs and applicable state government incentives.The Model Y can go up to 514km before needing to recharge, while the Atto 3 can go up to 420km.
Even though the Extended Range Atto 3 can go farther on a single charge, the Model Y’s performance is better. The Performance Model Y can go from 0 to 100km/hr in 3.7 seconds, while the Extended Range Atto 3 takes longer. The Model Y also has more power than both versions of the Atto 3.
However, the Performance Model Y costs more to run per kilometer than the Atto 3. The RWD Model Y is cheaper to run than the Atto 3.The Atto 3 is front-wheel drive, which makes it good for driving in slippery conditions. But the Model Y is better for handling and towing.
The BYD Atto 3 is smaller and cheaper than the Model Y. The Atto 3 is 296mm shorter, 46mm narrower, and 9mm shorter than the Model Y. However, the Atto 3 has a higher ground clearance than the Model Y, which means it sits higher off the ground. The Atto 3 has more cargo space than most other cars its size, with 1,340 litres of cargo space compared to the Model Y’s 853 litres with the back seats up.
While the BYD Atto 3 may be smaller in size compared to the Tesla Model Y, it still has some impressive features such as a higher ground clearance than the Model Y, making it a good option for drivers who frequently drive on rough terrain.
On the other hand, the Model Y provides more cargo space, making it a practical choice for families or individuals who need to transport larger items. Its longer length also gives it a more spacious and comfortable interior.
Ultimately, the decision between the BYD Atto 3 and the Tesla Model Y will come down to personal preference, budget, and intended use. However, both vehicles offer a range of impressive features and are set to be popular choices for those looking to purchase an electric SUV in Australia.
Interior Features of BYD Atto 3 and Tesla Model Y
The Model Y and Atto 3 have touchscreens to control the car, but they look different inside. The Atto 3 has a gear control in the centre console, while the Model Y has one on the steering wheel. The Atto 3’s touchscreen can turn sideways or up and down, while the Model Y’s screen stays in one place.
The Atto 3 has blue and white seats and a white dash, while the Model Y can come in black or white with a wooden accent. The Atto 3 has more types of charging ports than the Model Y, and from Q4 2022, it will have Android Auto and Apple CarPlay.
The Model Y and Atto 3 have similar exterior colours, but some colours cost extra. Both have white, grey, and blue options. The Model Y also has a black option, while the Atto 3 has a red option only for the Extended Range model. The Atto 3 comes with 18″ wheels, while the Model Y comes with 19″ wheels, but there is an upgrade to 20″ wheels for the Model Y.
Charging Speed and Compatibility
It’s clear that the Tesla Model Y has a faster and more dependable charging experience than the Atto 3. The Model Y can charge at a maximum speed of 210kW with DC charging, which is faster than the Atto 3’s maximum speed of 80kW. Additionally, the Model Y can charge at a rate of 11kW with AC charging, whereas the Atto 3 charges at a rate of 7kW.
The Model Y also has the advantage of being able to charge at both the Tesla Supercharger network and third-party public DC fast-chargers.
When it comes to driver assist technology, both the Model Y and Atto 3 are quite similar in terms of what they offer. Tesla’s autopilot system is highly regarded as one of the best driver assistance systems currently available on the market. Meanwhile, the Atto 3 boasts an impressive 360 degree camera feature that the Model Y does not have. This can help drivers have a better view of their surroundings and potentially make driving safer.
Service and Warranty Offerings
Teslaoffers a convenient way to book service appointments through its smartphone app. However, it is not clear whether BYD will provide a similar app for the Atto 3. Nevertheless, EV Direct has partnered with mycar to provide service for the Atto 3.
The Atto 3 comes with a battery and vehicle warranty that lasts for seven years. On the other hand, the Model Y has a warranty that lasts for 8 years or 160,000 km for the RWD variant, and 8 years or 192,000 km for the Performance variant.
Both the Atto 3 and Model Y have not yet received official safety ratings from ANCAP.
In conclusion, the Model Y and Atto 3 are quite different in terms of performance, range, features, and price. However, both cars offer good options for the limited EV market in Australia.The Model Y is a well-known EV brand that offers more charging options, more space, better performance, but at a much higher price. The Atto 3 is a newcomer to the market with good EV features and a promise of high quality, but it’s more affordable.